Education News

Utah Moves Closer to a Statewide Cellphone Ban in Schools

A universal cellphone ban in Utah public schools is gaining traction, with lawmakers overwhelmingly backing a proposal that would significantly limit phone use during class time. The bill, spearheaded by Sen. Lincoln Fillmore, aims to shift the current approach, making restrictions the norm rather than the exception.

Lawmakers Push for a Statewide Ban

Right now, schools in Utah can decide their own policies on cellphone use. Some have already implemented measures like magnetic locking pouches to keep students off their phones during class. But according to Fillmore, the lack of a standardized policy effectively means there is no restriction at all.

The Senate Education Committee unanimously supported the bill, SB178, sending it to the full Senate for consideration. If passed, school districts would have to create a policy on cellphone use. If they don’t, the default would be a strict ban on phones during instructional time.

“The question that (school districts) are asking now is, ‘how can we restrict these devices so we are minimizing the damage that they have on kids’ health and academic performance?’” Fillmore said. “But by passing this bill, we change the default and just change the question that local districts ask in an important way.”

What the Bill Means for Students and Schools

Under SB178, students wouldn’t be able to use any device capable of sending or receiving calls, messages, or data during class. This includes smartphones, smartwatches, and personal digital assistants.

Utah school cellphone ban

There are exceptions, though. Schools would be able to outline specific cases where phones are permitted, including emergencies and medical necessities. But for everyday use? Students would have to keep their devices away.

Fillmore pointed to positive results from schools that have already implemented similar bans. He said research shows improvements in academic performance, mental health, and even reductions in bullying.

No Funding for Locking Pouches

Initially, Fillmore proposed a $4.8 million fund to help schools buy magnetic locking pouches or similar storage solutions. That part of the plan has been scrapped.

Instead, students may simply be required to keep their phones in their backpacks. The decision follows concerns from some lawmakers about the cost of the pouches and reports that students found ways around them—like bringing a second phone to lock away while keeping their real device in use.

A Broader Trend Toward Classroom Phone Bans

Utah isn’t the only place taking steps to limit phone use in schools. Across the country, more states and districts are considering similar policies, citing concerns over distraction, cyberbullying, and the negative impact on mental health.

Recent studies support the move. A report from the London School of Economics found that banning phones in schools led to a 6.4% increase in test scores, with the biggest gains among struggling students.

While some parents and students may push back against the restrictions, Fillmore argues that the goal isn’t to cut students off from technology altogether—it’s to ensure it’s being used in a way that benefits their education rather than hinders it.

Comments

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *