Montana’s Republican Senators Call for Accountability After Lawyer’s Comments at Legal Training
A group of 19 Republican state senators, led by Senator John Fuller of Kalispell, is calling for the State Bar of Montana to issue an apology after a lawyer’s remarks at a training session this spring sparked controversy. The senators argue that the comments made by the lawyer, Jim Goetz, during a panel hosted by the Bar were not only inappropriate but also implicitly endorsed by the organization itself.
The controversy stems from remarks made by Goetz, a well-known Montana lawyer, during a panel at a continuing legal education (CLE) seminar held in April. Goetz, who is recognized for his work on stream access laws and challenging state policies, criticized Republican Governor Greg Gianforte, the GOP-controlled legislature, and the Montana Supreme Court. He referred to a recent Supreme Court decision as a “piece of s***” and disparaged the governor using an offensive nickname, calling him “Gianforeskin.”
The senators, in their letter to State Bar President Toni Tease, express their concerns about the tone and content of Goetz’s comments. They claim that the Bar’s sponsorship of the event amounted to an implicit endorsement of his statements. They demand that the State Bar apologize to its members, the Republican Party, and Governor Gianforte, and also issue new guidelines to ensure that future events foster a diversity of viewpoints.
Lawyer’s Remarks Spark Political Firestorm
At the heart of the controversy are Goetz’s comments, which have set off a political firestorm in Montana. During the panel, titled “Portraits in Courage-Unpopular Causes and Representing the Unrepresentable,” Goetz was one of several speakers who offered insights into their careers, particularly their work on controversial legal issues.
Goetz’s critiques, however, appeared to cross the line for many, particularly Republican lawmakers who have long expressed concerns over what they see as biases within Montana’s judiciary and legal institutions. The lawyer’s inflammatory language seemed to target the state’s conservative leadership, leading the senators to question whether the State Bar should have allowed such rhetoric to be aired during a Bar-sponsored event.
While Goetz clarified that he was speaking solely on his own behalf, not as a representative of the State Bar, the senators argue that the Bar’s endorsement of the event still reflects poorly on the organization’s stance on political discourse. Goetz’s remarks, which also included labeling certain laws passed by the legislature as “pieces of garbage,” were particularly upsetting for the lawmakers, who accuse him of spreading partisan animosity at a State Bar event.
The Senators’ Response: Apology and Guidelines Demanded
In their letter, the 19 Republican senators make several demands of the State Bar of Montana. They insist that the organization issue an official apology to both the Republican Party and Governor Gianforte for Goetz’s remarks. The senators also call for a broader review of the Bar’s guidelines for its events, urging the implementation of policies that ensure a more balanced representation of viewpoints.
The letter highlights the senators’ concern about the lack of diversity in perspectives during Bar-sponsored events. They argue that while the seminar panel featured several prominent legal figures, including a Montana Supreme Court justice and a retired district judge, the focus of the discussion seemed overwhelmingly hostile toward conservative political figures and policies. The lawmakers request that future Bar events include speakers who represent a wider range of political ideologies and legal perspectives.
As part of their demands, the senators have asked President Tease to respond by January 6, offering both an apology and a set of guidelines for future events. Additionally, they have requested that the State Bar’s response be published in the next issue of The Montana Lawyer and sent to all State Bar members.
State Bar Responds: No Immediate Action
In response to the letter, State Bar President Toni Tease expressed her intent to appear before the Senate Judiciary Committee on January 7. Tease emphasized that the Bar’s executive committee had not yet discussed the letter or formulated a response but reiterated that the organization does not condone the actions of individual members as reflecting its official stance.
Tease also clarified that Goetz’s comments, though provocative, were made in a personal capacity and should not be interpreted as the views of the State Bar as a whole. She added that the Bar would continue to uphold the principles of free speech while also considering the need for civility and respect in legal discussions.
Political Tensions in Montana’s Judicial Landscape
The conflict between the Republican senators and the State Bar is part of a broader trend of rising political tensions over the state’s judiciary. Lawmakers in Montana, particularly those aligned with the Republican Party, have voiced increasing concerns about what they perceive as a liberal bias in the judicial branch and legal organizations. These tensions have flared up in recent years, with accusations of political influence affecting judicial rulings and legal discourse.
The ongoing friction between state lawmakers and the judicial branch has led to calls for reform in how Montana’s legal institutions operate. Some Republicans argue that the State Bar and the courts are overly influenced by liberal ideologies, while others push for greater transparency and accountability within the system.
As the situation unfolds, all eyes will be on the State Bar’s response to the senators’ demands and whether this incident sparks further debates about the role of political views in the legal profession in Montana.
Comments